COMPARE YOUR OPTIONS
HVAC repair vs replacement calculator
Put repair and replacement on the same timeline. Use your quotes and operating-cost assumptions to compare the costs you can identify today.
Instant results No email required Print or save your result
Start with two written quotes
Enter a complete repair price and a complete replacement price. Add annual maintenance and energy costs if you have a reasonable basis for them. Keep the scope and comparison period consistent.
01 / YOUR INPUTS
Compare your two cost scenarios
Use your own measurements, quotes or equipment inventory. Fields marked optional can be left blank.
02 / YOUR RESULT
Useful numbers. Clear assumptions.
See both cost totals for the same period, the difference between them, and exactly which costs you included.
- Review the inputs behind every result
- Download a text copy or print
- Recalculate any time your inputs change
Save your result to share with the service team. Your inputs are not sent automatically.
METHOD & ASSUMPTIONS
A simple comparison over the same period
For each option, the calculator adds the upfront quote to the annual energy and maintenance amounts multiplied by your chosen number of years. A blank optional amount is excluded at $0 and identified in the result. Entering zero means you intentionally assumed no cost for that item.
Use equipment-specific estimates, service records or a documented energy assessment. A whole-building utility bill may include lighting, hot water and other loads. Do not treat that entire bill as the energy cost of one HVAC system. The tool does not infer savings from equipment age.
Scenario total = upfront cost + years × (annual energy cost + annual maintenance cost).
READ YOUR RESULT
A few useful answers
Does the lower total mean I should choose that option?
No. It identifies the lower cost within your assumptions. Safety, repair feasibility, recurring faults, comfort and disruption still require a system-specific review. ENERGY STAR also identifies frequent repairs and rising bills as reasons to discuss the overall system with a contractor.
What if I do not know the annual costs?
Leave them blank and compare the upfront quotes first. The result will show the omitted categories. You can then add documented estimates or try several reasonable scenarios; a single uncertain assumption should not decide the project.
Can I use this for a rooftop unit or heat pump?
Yes, if both quotes describe comparable outcomes and cover the same equipment. Include applicable labor, removal, controls, access and installation work consistently. For a partial repair versus a complete system replacement, note the difference in scope before interpreting the totals.
Sources & further reading
Method reviewed November 1, 2026. Manufacturer references explain the approach; use documentation for your exact equipment.
- ENERGY STAR: When is it time to replace?System condition and repair history; no published savings percentage is assumed by this tool.
Keep planning
All resources & toolsAIRPLEX MECHANICAL · NYC & NORTHERN NJ
Bring a comparison worth discussing.
Share the equipment model, diagnosis and competing scopes with Airplex. Request a review of the work your building needs.