05
Define acceptance before comparing proposals
A useful acceptance plan names the sequence behavior being checked, the available machines and the relevant operating conditions. It should cover the transitions that matter to the complaint, with local equipment protections intact. Agree how command, response and delivered plant conditions will be recorded. A statement that the controls were adjusted is too broad to evaluate.
Separate restored function from a proposed efficiency benefit. Shorter run time on one machine can be offset by another plant component or a changed load. Any savings evaluation needs an appropriate baseline and consistent measurement boundaries.
The closeout should retain the revised narrative, change record, trend evidence, unresolved mechanical findings and the person responsible for remaining tests. For planned maintenance, retain the accepted sequence and plant baseline so later checks can compare operation with the agreed behavior.