Review the proposed ventilation response

CO2 Demand-Controlled Ventilation: Reviewing a Proposal

A proposal that says “add CO2 sensors and reduce outdoor air” leaves important decisions unanswered. Ask how the system will respond to changing occupancy, unreliable readings and the building’s other ventilation needs.

Airplex Mechanical resources Reviewed November 16, 2026

Start here

What belongs in a CO2 demand-controlled ventilation proposal?

A usable proposal connects each served zone and occupancy assumption to its outdoor-air design basis, sensor arrangement, control sequence and verification plan. It also explains calibration, fault response and ongoing responsibility. CO2 feedback is one input to ventilation control; a reading alone cannot certify indoor-air quality or supply a universal safe setpoint.

Start with the rooms the control will represent

Make a room list beside the equipment list. A meeting room with occasional dense occupancy may behave differently from the adjacent office, even if both connect to one air handler. Record the proposed control zones, usual occupied hours and any changes of use. Ask the designer which assumptions govern the outdoor-air requirement and how the proposed system represents each zone.

Keep total supply airflow separate from outdoor airflow. A large recirculating supply quantity does not answer how much outdoor air reaches an occupied area. Likewise, a damper-position percentage is a command or position, not an airflow measurement. The proposal should identify the quantity it will control and the evidence that will establish delivery.

Make the sensor scope specific

DOE FEMP’s February 2024 assessment guide links demand-controlled ventilation with dependable CO2 sensing, appropriate occupied-space representation, calibration and a fault-tolerant strategy. Its discussion is an assessment framework, not a universal ppm trigger or a sequence to copy into every building.

Ask for the exact sensor model, measurement range, location and served zone. Request the manufacturer’s calibration or verification requirements and the proposed handover record. “Factory calibrated” and a future maintenance responsibility answer different questions. Record who can review an unexpected reading and who receives the resulting finding.

References: [1]

Read normal operation and fault behavior together

A sequence is the written explanation of how the controls respond in the intended operating modes. Ask the controls designer to identify occupied and unoccupied modes, project-specific ventilation limits and interactions with other system functions. A named control platform or a graphic showing CO2 does not supply this explanation.

The fault section should cover the conditions the design team considers relevant, such as unavailable, stale or implausible readings and communication loss. Ask which indication reaches the operator, who responds and what documented fallback applies. Do not choose the fallback from this article; it must suit the installed equipment and approved design.

If sensor work, controls programming and mechanical verification are provided by different parties, assign each deliverable. A proposal can include new sensors while leaving the logic and airflow verification elsewhere. That division may be reasonable, but it must be visible before the owner compares prices.

Worked example: two omissions that change the scope

This fictional proposal excerpt is a review exercise, not an Airplex project or an approved sequence: “Provide three CO2 sensors, connect to existing BMS and enable DCV for meeting rooms.” No calibration record, fault behavior or acceptance method accompanies it. The next action is to request specific missing evidence, not select a ppm value.

Illustrative proposal annotations
Proposal itemWhat is suppliedWhat remains openRequested response
Zone coverageThree meeting-room sensor locationsWhether each represents a distinct ventilation zoneMap rooms, equipment and design outdoor-air basis.
Sensor qualityModel number onlyInitial verification and ongoing calibration responsibilitySupply the method, record and responsible party.
Control logic“Enable DCV”Mode limits, stale-data handling and fault indicationProvide a reviewed sequence with fault behavior.
CompletionBMS graphics shownEvidence of response and outdoor airflowDefine functional and airflow records plus reviewer.

Define the evidence before signing off

Ask which documents will demonstrate the agreed work: sensor identification and verification records, the approved sequence revision, relevant point definitions, a functional-check record and airflow evidence appropriate to the scope. Keep measured results connected to equipment IDs and operating conditions. A screenshot of a plausible value proves only what that screen displayed at that time.

For a multi-tenant NYC or Northern New Jersey property, identify who controls the base-building outdoor-air system and who can provide access to tenant spaces. A tenant’s room schedule may differ from the central system schedule. Record that interface so it does not disappear between the controls and mechanical proposals.

Use the worksheet to assign one question at a time. Preserve the initial quote and add dated written responses. A general statement that the system is commissioned is less useful than an identifiable record of the functions checked and unresolved exclusions. The responsible project team determines acceptance against the actual requirements.

Put this guide to work

DCV proposal evidence register

Use one copy per proposal or system. Enter the document reference and owner for each open issue; blank cells are for your project, not recommended operating values.

Open each item to add your notes, then download the CSV to keep a copy. This tool does not save or submit your entries; do not rely on your browser restoring them.

Occupancy and occupied hours
Occupancy and occupied hours
Design outdoor-air basis and limits
Design outdoor-air basis and limits
Sensor model, location and zone representation
Sensor model, location and zone representation
Initial verification / calibration record
Initial verification / calibration record
Ongoing calibration responsibility
Ongoing calibration responsibility
Normal sequence and mode interactions
Normal sequence and mode interactions
Invalid reading / communication-loss response
Invalid reading / communication-loss response
Alarm recipient and response responsibility
Alarm recipient and response responsibility
Functional and airflow acceptance records
Functional and airflow acceptance records

Questions & answers

Is one CO2 level a universal ventilation target?

No. Ask the responsible designer to identify the applicable basis and approved sequence for the actual occupancy and system. This guide supplies no universal concentration trigger or damper instruction.

Can a low CO2 reading prove the room has good air quality?

No. It is one measurement with a location, time and quality limitation. The ventilation review still needs the building use, other relevant sources and the actual outdoor-air arrangement.

Does a calibration certificate prove the whole DCV system works?

It supports the sensor evidence within its stated scope. It does not by itself show that programming, equipment response and outdoor-air delivery satisfy the project requirements.

Sources & technical references

  1. DOE FEMP: Energy Efficiency and Indoor Environmental Quality Assessment Guide, February 2024

    Appendix F, PDF page 39: DCV sensing, calibration, occupied-space representation and fault-tolerant control. Read November 16, 2026; not a local design requirement.

NYC & Northern New Jersey

Bring the unanswered scope items

Share the served rooms, existing ventilation arrangement and proposal with Airplex Mechanical to discuss the mechanical and controls work that needs definition.

Discuss the ventilation proposalCall (347) 627-7146
Call Now Request Service