EQUIPMENT DOCUMENT REFERENCE

Mechanical Insulation Submittals: Comparing Thermal and Vapor Properties

Two insulation products can quote similar numbers while testing different conditions or describing different parts of the installed system.

Airplex Mechanical resources Reviewed November 16, 2026

Start here

What should a mechanical insulation comparison include?

Record thermal conductivity with its mean temperature and units, the proposed thickness, the precise vapor property and test conditions, and the complete jacket, seam and accessory specification. Compare those documents with the application's service conditions. Core material data alone does not establish installed condensation control, durability or compliance.

Start with the application and the document version

Describe what is being insulated: pipe, equipment or ductwork; indoor or outdoor; hot, cold or changing service. Record the operating temperature range, surrounding design conditions and the purpose being assessed. An energy-loss comparison, a condensation question and protection from physical damage may need different evidence.

Identify the exact product, form, thickness and facing. A tube, sheet and faced board from the same product family may have different properties or limitations. Retain the supplier's document revision and the specific row used rather than copying only the most favorable number.

Use the worksheet to track proposed systems side by side. The blank register is for your project; the examples in the article are illustrative or explicitly identified manufacturer document examples. None establishes a selected product or required thickness for your building.

Read conductivity with its temperature and units

Thermal conductivity is a material property used in heat-flow calculations. A lower value at matched conditions generally means less conduction through the same geometry and thickness. Compare W/(m·K) with W/(m·K), or a consistently converted customary-unit basis; a bare decimal can conceal a unit mismatch.

The mean temperature belongs with the conductivity value. ASTM C518-21's official scope describes testing flat specimens with a heat-flow meter, and its significance section identifies dependence on mean temperature, temperature difference and specimen condition. A property measured in the laboratory is not automatically an installed-system result.

Do not choose a conductivity value simply because it appears in the column nearest the pipe-fluid temperature. The relevant material mean temperature depends on the thermal conditions across the insulation. Ask the designer or supplier for the value and basis appropriate to the comparison.

References: [2]

Read an actual manufacturer table carefully

Armacell's current US AP/ArmaFlex + AP/ArmaFlex FS technical page separates formulation ranges. For its listed NBR/PVC range, the declared conductivity is at most 0.034 W/(m·K) at 10°C mean temperature and 0.037 W/(m·K) at 38°C mean temperature. The page identifies ASTM C177 and C518 methods.

That is a useful reminder that a product does not have one temperature-independent conductivity number. The same page lists vapor permeability in perm-inch and distinguishes NBR/PVC from EPDM products. Copy the exact applicable row and its footnotes.

These facts illustrate document structure only. They do not establish that this product, every thickness in its family or a particular jacket is suitable for your service. Use the actual proposed configuration and the manufacturer's complete limits.

References: [4]

Permeability is not permeance

NIA's Mechanical Insulation Design Guide distinguishes water-vapor permeability, commonly expressed in perm-inch, from permeance, commonly expressed in perms for a specified thickness or construction. The first describes a thickness-normalized material property; the second describes transmission through the stated specimen or assembly.

For an ideal homogeneous flat layer under matching conditions, permeance equals permeability divided by thickness. As a dimensional example, 0.05 perm-inch divided by 1 inch is 0.05 perm; divided by 0.5 inch it is 0.10 perm. This does not establish a pipe-system rating, a joint performance or the behavior of a composite facing.

ASTM E96/E96M-24a's official scope includes desiccant and water methods, and its significance section warns against transferring a result across different methods or test conditions. Record the method, temperature, humidity conditions and specimen thickness when comparing vapor data.

References: [1] [3]

Worked comparison: two attractive numbers leave two gaps

Consider hypothetical Proposal A: conductivity 0.034 W/(m·K) at 10°C mean temperature, 25 mm thickness, and a core permeability figure. Proposal B lists 0.036 W/(m·K) at 24°C mean temperature, also 25 mm thick, with a facing permeance figure. These are fictional proposal entries, not a ranking of commercial products.

A cannot be declared thermally better from 0.034 versus 0.036 because the mean temperatures differ. Request conductivity at the same applicable mean temperature, with test basis and material condition. B's facing permeance also cannot be ranked against A's core permeability without identifying the quantities and complete systems.

Suppose A additionally omits fitting and support details while B supplies them. B has a more complete document package for those locations, but that does not prove its thermal design is correct. Record completeness and numerical comparison separately so a missing detail cannot disappear behind a favorable decimal.

Hypothetical submittal comparison before clarification
FieldProposal AProposal BRequired clarification
Conductivity0.034 W/(m·K) at 10°C mean0.036 W/(m·K) at 24°C meanMatched mean temperature and method
Proposed thickness25 mm25 mmApplication-specific design basis
Vapor evidenceCore permeabilityFacing permeanceQuantity, units, specimen and test conditions
Fittings / supportsDetails missingDetails includedComplete applicable assembly review

Evaluate the installed system around the core material

The proposed insulation system includes joints, seams, adhesives, facings, terminations, fittings and support interfaces. Ask which document defines each component and how the materials are intended to work together. A core test does not verify an installed seam or a damaged jacket.

Separate vapor-control function from weather and physical protection. Record outdoor exposure provisions and compatibility of the specified accessories. Request the exact details for difficult locations such as equipment connections or removable service areas; a straight-pipe data sheet does not complete those interfaces.

Keep service-temperature limits and any fire-performance documentation attached to the exact material, thickness and assembly to which they apply. A broad product-family statement should not be expanded into universal approval. This guide does not prescribe installation methods or certify a finished system.

References: [1] [4]

Turn the comparison into a focused review request

List each unresolved item with its effect on the decision: missing matched-temperature conductivity, an unidentified vapor test, an omitted facing detail or an unclear service limit. Assign the supplier or designer who will answer and keep the written response with the submittal.

For condensation concerns, provide the relevant fluid and surrounding design conditions to the responsible designer. A room dew-point calculation alone does not choose insulation thickness or guarantee a dry surface at every support. Ask the project review to address the intended complete system.

After selection, retain the approved material schedule and document revisions with the handover. If a product or thickness changes, reopen the affected comparison. Similar appearance or the same nominal thickness does not establish equivalent documented properties.

Put this guide to work

Insulation material and system comparison register

Fill the proposal columns using exact document entries. Use the last column for the person responsible for aligning conditions or supplying the missing system detail.

Open each item to add your notes, then download the CSV to keep a copy. This tool does not save or submit your entries; do not rely on your browser restoring them.

Application and service / ambient conditions
Application and service / ambient conditions
Exact product, formulation, form and thickness
Exact product, formulation, form and thickness
Conductivity, units and mean temperature
Conductivity, units and mean temperature
Vapor property: permeability or permeance / units
Vapor property: permeability or permeance / units
Vapor method, humidity, temperature and specimen thickness
Vapor method, humidity, temperature and specimen thickness
Facing / jacket and weather protection
Facing / jacket and weather protection
Seams, fittings, supports and termination details
Seams, fittings, supports and termination details
Adhesives / accessories and compatibility
Adhesives / accessories and compatibility
Service limits and applicable assembly evidence
Service limits and applicable assembly evidence
Design basis, comparison result and approval record
Design basis, comparison result and approval record

Continue with a related decision

Questions & answers

Is the lowest conductivity automatically the best choice?

No. Compare at matching conditions, then assess the required thickness and complete system against service, vapor, exposure and project criteria. A single property cannot settle the selection.

Can I compare 0.05 perm-inch with 0.05 perm?

Not as identical values. They represent different quantities. Obtain the thickness, material or assembly basis and matching test conditions before making a comparison.

Does a low-permeability core remove the need to review seams?

No. The core property does not document the performance of installed joints, accessories or interfaces. Use the manufacturer's complete system details and the project's design requirements.

Will the dew-point calculator tell me the correct insulation thickness?

No. It describes air moisture and an entered surface comparison. Insulation design needs thermal properties, geometry, fluid and ambient conditions, surface characteristics and the relevant project criteria.

Sources & technical references

  1. NIA: Mechanical Insulation Design Guide, Materials and Systems

    Physical-property definitions, permeability versus permeance, and complete material/facing/accessory context. No generic thickness or older referenced edition adopted. Reviewed November 16, 2026.

  2. ASTM C518-21: Steady-State Thermal Transmission Properties by Heat Flow Meter

    Official active-edition scope and significance/use text, especially condition dependence; not the full purchased test procedure. Reviewed November 16, 2026.

  3. ASTM E96/E96M-24a: Gravimetric Determination of Water Vapor Transmission Rate

    Official active edition, scope and significance/use sections: method and exposure-condition limits. No procedure reproduced. Reviewed November 16, 2026.

  4. Armacell US: AP/ArmaFlex + AP/ArmaFlex FS technical specifications

    Current manufacturer table: named formulation ranges, conductivity mean temperatures, vapor-permeability units and method, and product-specific footnotes. Document-reading example, not a universal specification. Reviewed November 16, 2026.

NYC & Northern New Jersey

Bring a complete insulation submittal

For a hydronic or ductwork project in NYC or Northern New Jersey, share the system, proposed material schedule and unresolved document questions. Airplex Mechanical can discuss the mechanical scope; insulation design criteria and specialist review should be named in the project responsibilities.

Discuss the mechanical scopeCall (347) 627-7146
Call Now Request Service