CDU SUBMITTAL COMPARISON

Comparing CDU Ratings: Capacity, Approach Temperature and Pump Head

A larger kW figure can describe a different operating condition. Put the rating basis beside the capacity before deciding what either proposal establishes.

Airplex Mechanical resources Reviewed November 16, 2026

Start here

What makes two CDU capacity ratings comparable?

Compare liquid-to-liquid coolant distribution units at a shared thermal and hydraulic basis: fluid, facility supply temperature, technology supply temperature, flow on each side and pressure information at that flow. Include the pump operating mode and document revision. Ask the suppliers for performance at the project’s stated conditions; a headline maximum does not establish suitability for the proposed installation.

Read the conditions attached to the kW value

A liquid-to-liquid CDU transfers heat between the technology cooling system, or TCS, and the facility water system, or FWS. The Open Compute Project (OCP) performance-rating paper identifies capacity, flow conditions and coolant type as important reporting information. Keep those conditions with the number when copying it from a submittal.

For a concrete documentation example, Vertiv’s XDU450 data sheet, revision R06/21, lists 453 kW at a 4°C approach and 975 kW at an 8°C approach. These are published vendor ratings from that document, not two interchangeable capacities or a recommendation for this model. A current project needs its own supplier-confirmed selection.

References: [1] [2]

Separate approach temperature from loop temperature rise

OCP defines approach temperature difference as TCS supply temperature minus FWS supply temperature. It compares the fluid leaving toward the IT equipment with the facility fluid arriving at the CDU. A supply-to-return temperature change within one loop is a different comparison.

In an illustrative rating statement, facility supply at 32°C and technology supply at 37°C give a 5°C approach: 37 − 32 = 5. Those two temperatures alone reveal neither the heat transferred nor the flow. They are one part of the rating basis, not a complete selection.

When a proposal says only “5°C differential,” ask which two measurement points it means. Put the answer into the comparison sheet using the supplier’s labels. That simple clarification prevents a loop temperature rise from being mistaken for the heat exchanger’s approach.

References: [1]

Read pressure together with flow and pump mode

The hydraulic question has two sides. The technology circuit needs an available pressure-versus-flow basis, while the facility circuit imposes a pressure loss. OCP treats these separately. Ask where the stated boundary sits so a component figure is not mistaken for the pressure available to the external system.

The cited Vertiv sheet reports different secondary flow and pressure values for single-pump and dual-pump operation, and separately states primary pressure drop. This illustrates why “two pumps” is not a complete operating description. Record the mode used for the quoted performance and ask what documentation covers the project’s required operating cases.

Keep units visible. If one proposal uses pressure and another uses metres of fluid head, ask the reviewer to reconcile them using the specified fluid. A number copied without its units, fluid basis or flow point is not ready for a purchasing comparison.

References: [1] [2]

Worked example: the larger headline leaves a question open

The fictional proposals below illustrate a documentation review. The project comparison basis is 300 kW at 32°C facility supply and 37°C technology supply, with fluids and hydraulic requirements still to be confirmed by the project team. These values are teaching inputs, not recommended design conditions.

Proposal B’s 400 kW headline exceeds Proposal A’s 300 kW, but B is stated at a 10°C approach and a different facility temperature. It does not yet document performance at the example’s 5°C approach. The defensible result is “supplier response needed,” not “B is oversized” or “A is selected.”

Ask both suppliers to return the same completed basis, including the missing fluid and hydraulic information. A revised performance statement may resolve the gap. Preserve the revision that answers it so the commercial proposal and technical review refer to the same configuration.

Fictional partial rating statements; no real products are compared
FieldProposal AProposal BReview finding
Headline capacity300 kW400 kWDifferent rating bases require reconciliation
FWS / TCS supply32°C / 37°C25°C / 35°CA describes the example temperature pair; B does not
Calculated approach5°C10°CThese are different conditions
Fluids and concentrationsNot suppliedNot suppliedRequest both sides
Flow, pressure and pump modeIncompleteIncompleteNeither proposal is technically complete

Make the review outcome explicit

Use three document statuses in the worksheet: not provided, provided, or requires technical review. “Provided” means the record exists; it does not mean the requirement is met. Add the reviewer’s disposition and the remaining question to the same row.

Keep supporting details that change the supplied arrangement attached to the comparison: model and options, connection boundary, document revision and exclusions. If an option changes after review, ask which performance statement still applies. The responsible designer and equipment suppliers determine suitability; the worksheet helps them see precisely what has and has not been established.

Put this guide to work

Two-proposal CDU rating comparison

Enter values exactly as stated, including units and document references. Use “not provided,” “provided” or “requires technical review” in the status column. The worksheet records gaps; it does not select a winner.

Open each item to add your notes, then download the CSV to keep a copy. This tool does not save or submit your entries; do not rely on your browser restoring them.

Model and supplied options
Model and supplied options
Capacity at agreed conditions
Capacity at agreed conditions
FWS and TCS fluids / concentrations
FWS and TCS fluids / concentrations
FWS supply / TCS supply / approach
FWS supply / TCS supply / approach
FWS flow / CDU pressure loss
FWS flow / CDU pressure loss
TCS flow / available external pressure
TCS flow / available external pressure
Pump operating mode / required cases
Pump operating mode / required cases
Performance curves / boundaries / exclusions
Performance curves / boundaries / exclusions

Continue with a related decision

Questions & answers

Is a smaller CDU approach temperature always better?

It is one comparison variable, not an automatic ranking. Ask what capacity the supplier documents at the project’s temperature pair, fluid and flow conditions, then have the complete selection reviewed. Comparing one unit’s minimum approach with another unit’s maximum capacity can mix unrelated operating points.

Can we correct a published rating using a percentage?

Do not invent a correction factor for missing conditions. Request the manufacturer’s performance data or a selection for the stated project basis. If a calculation method is supplied, preserve its limits and inputs with the result so the technical reviewer can assess its applicability.

Does a CDU’s rated kW prove that the building can receive that heat?

No. The equipment rating and the facility’s ability to support the proposed arrangement are separate parts of the review. Link the CDU comparison to the project’s facility information and responsible designer. A complete CDU submittal cannot fill a missing building-system assessment.

Sources & technical references

  1. OCP: Liquid to Liquid CDU Test Methodology and Performance Rating

    Revision 1.0, sections 3.3.2–3.3.2.4. Reviewed November 16, 2026. Cover says August 2024; revision table shows 11/01/2024. Cited by revision because these dates differ.

  2. Vertiv XDU450 CDU data sheet, SL-07622 (R06/21)

    Published vendor rating example, specification page 4. Reviewed November 16, 2026; historical document illustration, not a current equipment recommendation.

NYC & Northern New Jersey

Bring the rating basis to the conversation

For a NYC or Northern New Jersey project, share the CDU model, proposed mechanical work and the rating questions still open. Airplex Mechanical can discuss its scope alongside the project designer and equipment suppliers.

Discuss the CDU mechanical scopeCall (347) 627-7146
Call Now Request Service