Start here
How should you compare DOAS and ERV proposals?
Separate three functions: delivering outdoor air, actively heating or cooling and dehumidifying it, and recovering energy from an exhaust stream. A dedicated outdoor air system can include energy recovery; an ERV can work with separate zone-conditioning equipment. Compare selected components, design conditions and controls, not two equipment labels.
Give each function an owner
Greenheck’s 2025 application guide describes outdoor-air treatment separate from zone conditioning and shows recovery either combined with equipment or serving it separately. Its examples explain possible arrangements; they do not establish savings or compliance for this project.
For the comparison, ask three questions. Where does the outdoor air enter and reach the occupied zones? Which equipment actively changes its temperature and removes moisture? Which outgoing airstream, if any, supports energy recovery? Keep each answer attached to a selected model and drawing reference.
References: [1]
Three arrangements to trace through the proposal
These simplified arrangements are reading aids, not design recommendations. A real project can add components, use different connections or assign more of the room load to the outdoor-air system. The purpose is to expose those differences rather than rank the labels.
| Arrangement | Outdoor-air and recovery path | Active treatment responsibility | Question to resolve |
|---|---|---|---|
| ERV plus zone unit | Outdoor air through ERV; identified exhaust stream supports recovery | Separate zone equipment or other documented treatment | Can that equipment handle the residual temperature and moisture duty in relevant modes? |
| DOAS without recovery | Outdoor air through dedicated treatment unit; exhaust handled separately | Selected DOAS heating/cooling/dehumidification functions | Which functions and entering/leaving conditions are actually included? |
| DOAS with recovery | Outdoor and approved exhaust streams serve recovery within or upstream of DOAS | DOAS treatment after recovery, with zone equipment as designed | How are recovery, active treatment, bypass/frost modes and zone operation coordinated? |
Put both options on one condition basis
Start with the designer’s required outdoor airflow and the zones it serves. Record the entering-air conditions and required supply condition used in each equipment selection. Include temperature and moisture information rather than copying only cooling tonnage. Ask which operating cases were evaluated, including periods when the space needs ventilation but little sensible cooling.
Next identify the exhaust source available for recovery and the design team’s basis for using it. The mere presence of an exhaust fan does not confirm an appropriate recovery connection. Keep exhaust suitability, routes and operating availability as explicit project questions.
Record the unit arrangement and the zone-system responsibility together. A proposal that treats outdoor air to a specified condition can leave different room loads with the local units than a proposal that supplies air after recovery alone. The total project comparison needs those retained-system assumptions; a lower equipment price can otherwise hide a shifted duty.
Worked example: equal airflow, different promised functions
Fictional project: two occupied office zones share an outdoor-air requirement established by their designer. Both offers state 1,200 CFM, solely as an example quantity. Option A offers an ERV with existing zone units retained. Option B offers a DOAS with energy recovery and active cooling, dehumidification and heating. Neither is accepted merely from these labels.
| Comparison item | Option A: ERV + retained units | Option B: DOAS + recovery | Reviewer annotation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outdoor airflow | 1,200 CFM stated; zone split omitted | 1,200 CFM; zone split shown | Ask A for the same zone schedule. |
| Moisture duty | Assumed to remain with existing units | Supply moisture condition stated in selection | Ask for A’s residual-load evidence and B’s full entering condition. |
| Recovery source | Existing exhaust named | Same exhaust named; connection shown | Confirm source suitability and simultaneous availability for both. |
| Low cooling demand | Ventilation operation described; zone response unclear | Separate outdoor-air sequence supplied | Compare humidity treatment when room cooling demand falls. |
| Completion records | Fan operation check only | Airflow and functional checks identified | Align verification scope before price comparison. |
Price the connections and responsibilities
For an occupied commercial property, trace access and routes as well as equipment. Identify who provides intake and exhaust connections, drains, utilities, controls interfaces and any work on retained zone systems. If the outdoor-air unit sits outside the tenant’s area, name the building contact who can authorize access and coordination.
Ask the proposals to describe maintenance access for both airstreams and all fitted treatment sections. A recovery module adds a function that must remain accessible; a separate ERV can create a second equipment location. Compare the practical arrangement rather than assuming one packaged cabinet always means a smaller project.
Keep claimed savings in a separate, documented analysis. Operating hours, weather, fan power, recovery performance and treatment duty affect the result. This comparison sheet organizes scope; it does not produce an annual-energy estimate or establish which standards apply to the building.
Close the comparison with a written response
Mark an omitted function as not stated until the proposer answers. Do not write “included” because it appears in the model family’s brochure; an option may be absent from the actual selection. Ask for revised selections and drawings when an answer changes the equipment.
The useful final comparison names outdoor-air delivery, active treatment, recovery and remaining zone duties in each option. Attach the design basis and completion evidence, then have the responsible project team evaluate suitability. Airplex can discuss the related mechanical service and installation scope from that clearer brief.
Put this guide to work
Two-proposal outdoor-air function matrix
Enter the same project requirement once, then copy each proposal’s actual document evidence. Keep unresolved functions visible rather than assuming a product label includes them.
Open each item to add your notes, then download the CSV to keep a copy. This tool does not save or submit your entries; do not rely on your browser restoring them.
Zones and occupied hours
Outdoor airflow and distribution
Entering-air temperature / moisture basis
Required leaving-air temperature / moisture
Active cooling and dehumidification
Active heating and tempering
Recovery device and exhaust source
Remaining zone-conditioning duty
Controls, low-load and fault modes
Connections and maintenance access
Acceptance measurements and records
Continue with a related decision
Questions & answers
Does an ERV provide the same dehumidification as a DOAS cooling section?
Do not assume equivalent treatment. Identify recovery performance and active moisture-removal functions at the actual conditions, then ask who handles the remaining load.
Can a single proposal include both DOAS and energy recovery?
Yes. Recovery can be integrated with or connected to a dedicated outdoor-air system. Record the actual air path and components.
If both proposals state the same CFM, are they equivalent?
No. Confirm the airflow basis and zones, then compare the supplied air condition, exhaust arrangement, controls, retained-system duty and verification scope.
Sources & technical references
- Greenheck: Applying Rooftop Units and Dedicated Outdoor Air Systems, RTU/100-25, 2025
Pages 1–4 read November 16, 2026 for outdoor-air treatment, zone-system separation and recovery integration. The matrices are original educational examples, not Greenheck selections.
NYC & Northern New Jersey
Compare the complete functions
Bring both proposals and the available outdoor-air design basis to Airplex Mechanical to discuss equipment, connections and service responsibilities.
Discuss the outdoor-air scopeCall (347) 627-7146